Robert McCloskey
[PDF] Download ô Lentil | by Ú Robert McCloskey
Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM By Robert McCloskey

Lentil cannot sing or even whistle longing to make music in some fashion, he provides himself with a harmonica and practices constantly wherever he is, especially in the bathtub, because there his tone is improved 100 percent A book that, along with its fun, truly illustrates the American scene.
  • Title: Lentil
  • Author: Robert McCloskey
  • ISBN: 9780140502879
  • Page: 335
  • Format: Paperback


Kathryn Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
I'm giving this five stars for the illustrations. The words are sweet, but I almost felt that the illustrations told the entire story just as well. Lentil is the most adorable boy and the story is nostalgic and fun and touching--poor Lentil cannot sing well, or whistle, but he loves music so he saves his money to buy a harmonica; and his harmonica playing soon saves the day! This is from the early 1940s but you could totally picture Opie Taylor from "Andy Griffith" reading this and getting inspi [...]
Click to Replay
Tricia Douglas Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Another of my favorite author of children's books. As a child I read all of his books, my favorite always being Homer Price and Make Way for Ducklings. They will go down in history. Plus his illustrations will always remind me of my childhood. Lentil shows show a boy who can't sing can still be musical AND save the day. All children should read this one.
Click to Replay
Deania Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
The book is cute and is revolved around music. A boy who does not have a lot of musical talent, finds a way to express himself musically through a harmonica. He finds his best place to practice and has fun while walking to school. It is good book.
Click to Replay
Matthew Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
To check out all my reviews: dancinginth3darkWhen researching about this authors bibliography I discover that some of his books are no longer in circulation which is disappointing at times but for this particular book I agree with the vast majority that this book should no longer be available for mass consumption.This book takes place in Alto, Ohio where we meet our main character named Lentil who loves to play the harmonica. Based on the illustrations the small town is depicted between the late [...]
Click to Replay
Erin Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
I cannot believe I never read this when I was little. Lentil, a young boy who cannot pucker his lips, has never been able to sing, nor can he whistle. What is a boy to do? He goes to the store and buys a harmonica and plays it all around town all the way to school. Everyone likes it. That is, everyone except Old Sneep. While everyone is preparing for Colonel Carter's return to town, Old Sneep is being an old grouch and decides to suck on a lemon, which causes the band to not play (their lips are [...]
Click to Replay
Rosa Cline Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
This is an old 'classic' book, illustrations are black and white but still very adorable. Lentil is a little boy that wants so bad to sing; but he simply can't. So he saves his money and gets a harmonica and teaches himself to play. He plays it everywhere he goes. A big parade to welcome a special town man coming to town is scheduled but when the train arrives with the man the bank can't play! But Lentil brings out his harmonica and saves the day!
Click to Replay
Dianna Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
I thought this book would be very long, but it's just oversized. The amount of text on the pages isn't too overwhelming. A very cute story about a boy named Lentil who can't sing but learns to play the harmonica instead. Then he and his harmonica help out the town at in a difficult (very funny!) situation.
Click to Replay
Stephanie Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
What a cute classic story. Robert McCloskey knows how to write fun and moralistic stories. The moral of this story: just because you don't have one talent doesn't mean you can't find another and in some way save the day.But don't forget to practice practice practice!!!
Click to Replay
Robert Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
A nice old fashioned kind of story about a boy who saves the day with his harmonica. Mr. McCloskey sure liked to draw church steeples. Practically every page has a church in it, and there are at least three churches in the town of Alto, Ohio, judging by the endsheet illustration.
Click to Replay
Angie Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
I wish I had known about this book when my oldest son wanted a harmonica for his birthday. It would have been the perfect go-along gift. Such a sweet story about a boy who, though not musically inclined, wants to make music. He can't carry a tune, and can't even pucker his lips to whistle. So he buys a harmonica and practices during every spare moment. The day comes when that practice comes in handy and he saves the day with his harmonica tunes. Worthwhile themes such as community, giving and gr [...]
Click to Replay
Melanie Dulaney Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
What a blast from the past! I found a nearly new condition copy of Lentil at a resale shop and bought it for my "Grandma" book shelf because it bears award-winning author Robert McCloskey's name. But I had forgotten how much I love this one--the illustrations are beautifully done and reflect another time perfectly. The themes of being yourself, searching until you find your niche, giving to others are all there. Teachers (and Grandmas) can use this book for teaching so many reading skills or jus [...]
Click to Replay
Susan Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Ugh! There were many annoying factors to this story - the hero worshipping, the playing nice to get money from the rich guy, the supreme maleness of the book (I am giving allowances for that given the time the book was written), the requirement that the reader stretch credulity to the ridiculousness (and I give no allowances for that). BUT the main part that irked me was this book was obviously written by someone who knows nothing about playing band instruments, and yet he not only chose to writ [...]
Click to Replay
Luisa Knight Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
A fun story that has humorous, unpredictable twists and is charming! Just start reading it and you'll see.McCloskey's illustrations are a delight and I'm going to name him the "Children's Norman Rockwell" as he does such a fabulous job capturing old town America.Ages 3+
Click to Replay
Marius S Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Lemons always sound good when I read this book.
Click to Replay
Kim Bitner Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Named after its main character, Lentil is a story about discovering what makes us unique and using our gifts and abilities to help others. Unable to sing, Lentil seeks another musical expression and decides to master the harmonica. His talent and dedication combine and he becomes quite skilled on his instrument. The whole town gathers at the train station to welcome their most honoured citizen, Colonel Carter, but envious Old Sneep sabotages the event and the band is unable to play. Lentil's cou [...]
Click to Replay
Dorothy Carder Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
This was a good, quick book to read even though it was quite dated (Copyright 1940). It is fiction, but some things in the book may lead people to believe it was real. For example, the book is set in the fictional town of Alto, Ohio - home of the great Colonel Carter also fictional. The book is about a boy named Lentil who wants to be able to sing, but when he opens his mouth to only strange sounds come out. He can't even whistle. But then he gets the idea to buy a harmonica, and practices "when [...]
Click to Replay
Sanju Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
This is one of my favorite stories of all time. Little Lentil is great, but the guy who starts sucking the lemons there is just something about him that makes me laugh, even when I think about him. Someone who just gets so much pleasure out of spoiling it for everyone else. Why are people like that so hilarious to me? McCloskey is a very adored writer in our home. His gentle but beautiful way of carefully bringing out the personalities and feelings of his characters is so charming Of his stori [...]
Click to Replay
Crystal Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
This is an adorable book. The illustrations alone make it worthwhile reading--vivid, humorous, and nostalgic (although I guess they weren't nostalgic at the time it was written and first published). Lentil was a cute kid who didn't give up on his dream, and was rewarded for it. The story itself seemed far-fetched to me in several ways (Don't you purse your lips to play a harmonica too? It's been awhile since I've played around with one.), but this is a kids' book, so I guess it's not as big of a [...]
Click to Replay
Stan Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
This is a pleasant story from a bygone era. I wonder if children today would find it interesting and yet, the story's plot is used all the time in contemporary fiction for young people: an event is about to happen, the grown-ups bungle it, a young person—in this case Lentil—saves the day. But this is not an action-packed page turner by today's standards, the story is not over-the-top wacky, and Lentil's actions are far from heroic, yet he saves the day. The difference between this story and [...]
Click to Replay
Dusty Johnson Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Themes: Overcoming adversity, Practicing, Bravery, Unexpected Triumphs, MusicThis is a charming story and the penciled artwork added to that element. The interactions from the animals towards Lentil as he pursued his talents are quite cute and expressive. There are a lot of directional, spatial prepositions.*Spoiler* The last page jarred the story in a different direction with the moral of the story but it was fun anyhow.
Click to Replay
Paul Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Even before I cracked open the book, I could sense the puckered lips and the slurping of the lemon. McCloskey's simple black on white drawings convey small town life in Ohio between the first and second World Wars. In some ways it seems a little naive, but that is part of what helps it work. As for Lentil's finding an alternative to singing, which he couldn't do, his initiative was a benefit to himself and his community.
Click to Replay
Dolly Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
We've read several books by Robert McCloskey and have really enjoyed the simple, yet sincere tales that speak of an older time. This is another example of such a story. It's not our favorite of his tales, but it's a fun story to read aloud and has some interesting characters. We enjoyed reading this story together.
Click to Replay
Eyehavenofilter Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
This is one of those books you read as a child and reread as an adult and get more out of it in later life than you think.Lentil takes up the harmonica, having no idea how to use the little instrument but by sheer determination and practice he manages to master it quite well. Just goes to show you, it pays to be young and stubborn?
Click to Replay
Cathy Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
I used to love Robert McCloskey when I was young and saw this at the library. It was published in 1940 and it is set in a small town. What might make it interesting for kids today is the clothing and home furnishings that were popular back then (when their grandparents were young.) The story is a bit dated.
Click to Replay
Tracey Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Another wonderful book by Robert McCloskey. I remember checking this out from the Ames Public Library often when I was a kid. Great scene in it is when a tuba player in the band (during the parade) gets puckered up and unable to play b/c he sees someone sucking on a lemon! I recently bought a beat-up old library copy of this book - the original version in red. Very nostalgic.
Click to Replay
Katie Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Having a great time with this book for Five In a Row. DD immediately wanted to get a harmonica.Some topics we're drawing from the story:-Uniqueness/Talents-Ohio geography, flag, etc-Quality of sound/reverberations-Telling a story through pictures/sequencing-Narration-Playing with various instruments
Click to Replay
Maria Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Robert McCloskey is as good as capturing humans as he is at ducks. The pictures sing and far outshine the writing. Old Sneep is a perfect curmudgeon and Lentil is a wonderful ingenue. I also like that McCloskey's book always carry a wonderful sense of place, the small town captured here is no exception.
Click to Replay
Juliej Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
A classic! The charcoal drawings evoke a time when the book takes place. Written in the 1940's and depicting small town life when everyone knew each other, it tells the story of Lentil, a boy who was inseparable from his harmonica and saves the day in Alto, Ohio.
Click to Replay
Tanya Jun 07, 2020 - 10:23 AM
Loved the illustrations, especially when Lentil tries to sing around the animals. I liked that the status of hero was able to be achieved by a child thinking through and carrying out a simple act. And it was appreciated. Sweet story, but the illustrations were the best part to me
Click to Replay

Leave a Comment

Your Comment
Lentil By Robert McCloskey Lentil cannot sing or even whistle longing to make music in some fashion, he provides himself with a harmonica and practices constantly wherever he is, especially in the bathtub, because there his tone is improved 100 percent A book that, along with its fun, truly illustrates the American scene.

Share this article...
  • [PDF] Download ô Lentil | by Ú Robert McCloskey
    335 Robert McCloskey
  • thumbnail Title: [PDF] Download ô Lentil | by Ú Robert McCloskey
    Posted by:Robert McCloskey
    Published :2020-03-08T10:23:48+00:00